84.7 F
Charlotte Amalie
Monday, July 22, 2024
HomeNewsLocal newsNew Owners to Take Over Carambola Resort by End of Month

New Owners to Take Over Carambola Resort by End of Month

View of Carambola Resort with Hamms Bluff in the background. (Susan Ellis photo)
View of Carambola Resort with Hamms Bluff in the background. (Susan Ellis photo)

A thorn in the side of the Government Employees Retirement System may be removed by the end of the month, if the sale of Renaissance St. Croix Carambola Beach Resort and Spa goes through.

It is common knowledge, especially among government retirees, that GERS is heading for financial disaster in a few years because more money is being paid to retirees than is coming in from employees. Even government agencies are behind millions of dollars on their contributions.

The 151-room Carambola Resort on St. Croix’s northwest coast, under the Marriott brand, became the property of GERS after previous owners defaulted on a $15 million loan in May 2012. The loan’s purpose was to pay off bank loans, clear up liens and other financial matters and renovate the hotel. Reportedly, only a little more than $2 million was repaid.

The public mumbling when the loan was made grew into outcry when the retirement system foreclosed on the hotel and took over its management. In 2014, the board voted to sell the property.

News of the pending sale became public last week at an Economic Development Authority meeting. Marc Gordon of Davis Bay LLC – the company planning to buy the resort – talked about applying for tax benefits once the sale has been completed. Gordon is also the founder of Rubicon Company of New York.

Tom Bolt, attorney for GERS in this matter, confirmed the “goal is (to close) by the end of the month.” Originally, there may have been as many as 20 entities interested in purchasing Carambola, he said. At the end of the process, the final decision involves more than money but other factors such as the stability of the buyer, management of the facility and corporate brand, he said.

There is a confidentiality agreement between the buyer and seller, Bolt said, so he wouldn’t say more. According to Bolt and GERS administrator Austin Nibbs, a joint news release will announce the closing date and details of the sale.

Bolt and other news sources said Gordon plans to spend $10 million renovating the hotel and will retain Rick Carrington’s Aimbridge Hospitality to manage the facility. So far there has been no date given for reopening Carambola, but they plan to keep the hotel under the Marriott brand.

Nibbs said the deal wasn’t finalized yet and declined to say anything to the Source about the prospective sale.

Laurance Rockefeller founded the Carambola Resort in 1986. It is the only branded hotel on St. Croix. In addition to 151 rooms, the property has meeting rooms, restaurants, a dive shop, a spa and a sandy beachfront.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Keeping our community informed is our top priority.
If you have a news tip to share, please call or text us at 340-228-8784.

Support local + independent journalism in the U.S. Virgin Islands

Unlike many news organizations, we haven't put up a paywall – we want to keep our journalism as accessible as we can. Our independent journalism costs time, money and hard work to keep you informed, but we do it because we believe that it matters. We know that informed communities are empowered ones. If you appreciate our reporting and want to help make our future more secure, please consider donating.


  1. Have stayed at Carambola a couple of times. It is really lovely. Grounds were well-groomed. But it could use professional management for sure-from check-in to check-out. Did not care for the restaurant offerings, food was very average. I hope the new management is very considered in their first steps when taking over, and take the time to really understand the culture.

  2. “Confidentiality agreement between the buyer and seller????” Who is the Seller? Isn’t it the Government Retirement System?!!! Isn’t the Government Employees that own Carambola? What nonsense am I hearing now?!!! Really?

    “The final decision involves more than money.” What does that mean? More than money? What is more than money other than life and breath? Hope they are not giving away the farm like they did West Bay Grocery store, (11 million), Morgan Stanley “OOPS of $1.2 billion of risky mortgage debt , etc. etc. What is wrong with these people? Who are they thinking about in these negotiations? Not the employees, not the employees’ families or the people’s livelihood. My Goodness! Have some sense of decency and taking the people of the VI for idiots!