78.3 F
Charlotte Amalie
Saturday, July 24, 2021
HomeNewsLocal newsRacist Supreme Court Rulings on U.S. Territories Receive Congressional Hearing

Racist Supreme Court Rulings on U.S. Territories Receive Congressional Hearing

V.I Delegate Stacey Plaskett (Photo courtesy of Michael McQuerry)

A House resolution co-sponsored by V.I. Delegate Stacey Plaskett received a landmark congressional hearing on Wednesday, proposing that the Insular Cases – a series of racist Supreme Court decisions that put residents of U.S. territories on a “separate and unequal” footing – be rejected.

The Insular Cases created “an unprecedented category of unincorporated territories” with limited constitutional guarantees in 1901, Plaskett testified, and its decisions were “explicitly informed by racist assumptions, describing territory residents as “fierce, savage and restless people.”

“The irony is profound,” Plaskett said, that the likes of Alexander Hamilton and Camille Pisarro were considered “absolutely unfit to be citizens because they could not comprehend American, Anglo-Saxon principles.”

The racial animus with which the Insular Cases were decided – by some of the same Supreme Court justices who ruled in a contemporaneous case, Plessy v. Ferguson, to justify Jim Crow and racial segregation – are reason to reject them, supporters of H. Res. 279 argued.

Advertising (skip)
Advertising (skip)

The only difference is that Jim Crow is no longer law, but Insular Cases doctrine is, Plaskett said.

The impact of the precedent-setting cases isn’t just academic, according to Equally American Founder Neil Weare, whose nonprofit advocates equality for the 3.5 million U.S. citizens living in territories.

The Insular Cases have been cited in current and recent cases to argue that Supplemental Security Income benefits should be denied to the blind or disabled if they are territory residents; that territory residents should not vote for president; that their Medicaid benefits should be capped; and that search and seizure that would be illegal elsewhere in the U.S. is okay in the territories, Weare said.

“Although the resolution is non-binding, it’s an important first step to disrupt a status quo that’s existed far too long,” he said.

Not all of the territories support the resolution in its entirety, however.

Representatives from America Samoa and the Northern Mariana Islands expressed concern about losing their ability to control property ownership based on native birth or descent. Although the ancient cultural practice has been diluted in recent years, it would not be allowed under the Constitution’s equal protections, they said.

The hearing came on the same day that the Biden administration announced the nomination of Gustavo Gelpí, to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 1st Circuit in Boston. A San Juan native, Gelpi in 2011 wrote searingly of the mindset of the Insular Cases, using quotes from latter-day congressional leaders.

“… Asiatics, Malays, negroes and of mixed blood have nothing in common with us and centuries cannot assimilate them. They can never be clothed with the rights of American citizenship nor their territory be admitted as a State of the American Union,” one was quoted as saying.

Gelpi’s appointment fills the vacant seat of the late Juan Rafael Torruella, the first Hispanic jurist to sit on the first circuit, who likened the Insular Cases to “a regime of political apartheid.”

Michael Ramsey, a conservative constitutional scholar, agreed. “The Insular Cases are an abomination,” he wrote in 2020. “… The distinction between ‘incorporated’ and ‘unincorporated’ territories has no basis in the Constitution’s text or founding-era commentary.”

St. Croix attorney Semaj Johnson, a plaintiff in a federal voting rights case, Segovia v. United States, that did not prevail, applauded the hearing.

“Here we are for almost 100 years having no right to vote and the rest of the nation paying no attention to it,” Johnson said. “These hearings are an opportunity to right that. What’s exciting is that it’s the first time Congress is taking another look since these territories were acquired.”

After a vote by the House Natural Resources Committee, the resolution will move to the full House for consideration.

Prior to the Insular Case decisions, territories were given support and a pathway to statehood, Weare said. If the resolution passes, that case law would offer a framework going forward.

“Having the Insular Cases condemned is important to engaging the political process,” he said, “so each territory can be brought to the table to chart its path forward according to the will of its people.”

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Support local + independent journalism in the U.S. Virgin Islands

Unlike many news organizations, we haven't put up a paywall – we want to keep our journalism as accessible as we can. Our independent journalism costs time, money and hard work to keep you informed, but we do it because we believe that it matters. We know that informed communities are empowered ones. If you appreciate our reporting and want to help make our future more secure, please consider donating.





Comments Box SVG iconsUsed for the like, share, comment, and reaction icons
11 hours ago
Virgin Islands Source

Juju & Cece’s Lemonades and Treats is hosting a "Freco and Lemonade" event today from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. at Cultured Naturals Body Care located on Company Street in Christiansted, St. Croix.

The business, Juju & Cece’s Lemonades, evolved from a summer project put together by 4-year-old Juliett Reid-Ventura and 3-year-old Gracie Reid-Ventura. #visource #usvi #supportlocalbusiness
... See MoreSee Less

Juju & Cece’s Lemonades and Treats is hosting a Freco and Lemonade event today from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. at Cultured Naturals Body Care  located on Company Street in Christiansted, St. Croix. 

The business, Juju & Cece’s Lemonades, evolved from a summer project put together by 4-year-old Juliett Reid-Ventura and 3-year-old Gracie Reid-Ventura. #visource #usvi #supportlocalbusiness

Comment on Facebook

Cute as a button. Darling little princess. Please protect them

Make sure they Mask 😷 up.

Loving and trusting someone is such a risk and i don't wish any woman to be in the same shoes as i was sometime back when I caught my husband red-handed with my own best friend in our own bed. I couldn't believe it when I saw it and my heart started beating so fast and felt like my body is shaking then I ran straight to my elder sister's house. I cried so much and my sister left me to cry and told me it would help ease the pain I was feeling. Then she sat me down and asked me if I still love my husband and I told her yes of course, and she told me that we all learn and grow through mistakes and no one is perfect and told me that if I wanted my man back I should fight for him and never trust friends again.My sister told me to contact profisma+27783320386 who had helped her husband with financial issues and told me he will help me bring my man back. It took me weeks to think about it because we come from a strong religious background but things worsened because I could not even concentrate at work and i got fired, and after that, i remembered what my sister had told me about consulting with him. That's when I contacted him and told everything, he listened, and told me that he will solve all my problems in 48 hrs. Since it was my first time doing this, i could not believe his words just like that but i had to wait until the time he had promised. I was asked to buy materials to help me which I did, we begun the prayer and results were delivered in three days. My husband called me and asked me where I was, and he came straight to me and confessed how my best friend seduced him, and he was sorry to fall into her trap and showed me all the messages my best friend was sending to him and promised never to see her again and promised to love me and only me. That evening he took me to a romantic dinner, Since prophet isma helped me, I got a better paying job than the previous one, my husband is back to the old man I used to know and he loves me so much and does everything to see that am happy. Thank you so much prophet, your spells indeed work. If you're going through struggles, you can text him on WhatsApp +27783320386 or call him

Load more
Print Friendly, PDF & Email